Soldiers of the Russian army have endured more misery than any other fighting force in recent memory: massive losses, corrupt, cruel and incompetent officers, inadequate supplies, indifferent medical care and now, after four bloody years with little to show for that sacrifice, the surging success of their Ukrainian enemies.
Students of history will recall that the Russian Revolution was sparked by the mutiny of the Tsar's field armies on the Eastern Front in WWI - as well as the rebellion of Baltic Fleet sailors at Kronstadt naval base outside St Petersburg (which was bombed last week by Ukrainian drones). That this generation of Russian soldiers and sailors have endured their privations for so long, given the horrific scale of their casualties and paucity of success, is a matter of surprise to observers from more civilized societies. But now, as the following article reveals, all of the elements that have historically led to military mutinies are present for Russian troops in Ukraine. The most soul-destroying may be the Ukrainians' offensive successes, both at the front and striking the Russians' rear areas, including cities once considered untouchable. In addition to the lack of any hope of success for their own efforts, the troops must now confront the fact that, in many areas and perhaps overall, they are losing. There are no rumors or stories about mutinies to date, but that final blow to morale, on top of leadership's refusal to admit any problems, may be the last straw. JL
Brynn Tannehill reports in The Bulwark:
Hemingway famously observed that one goes bankrupt “gradually and then suddenly.” The same can be said of armies. The biggest army does not automatically win. Armies fall apart in months due to a combination of poor leadership, lack of logistic support, exhaustion, corrupt regimes, failed offensives, and broken morale. Many of the conditions for Russian army collapse have been in place for a long time: corruption is endemic, commanders extort money from their troops, soldiers are punished with violence, tactics have resulted in high losses with minimal gains, all with predictable effects on combat effectiveness. (And) the most important condition - logistics - is now trending in the wrong direction. There is no hope of breakthrough. The spring offensive of 2026 has failed. (But) the best guarantor of poor Russian leadership is Putin's (good) health.