Russian Paratroops and Marines Refuse Orders For Krynky Human Wave Assaults

Russian troops outnumber Ukrainians 4 to 1 on the east bank of the Dnipro around Krynky, yet the Russians have been unable to push the Ukrainian Marines back across the river. Increasingly frustrated Russian commanders, having squandered expendable Storm Z units, have begun ordering more elite paratrooper and naval infantry units to adopt the same tactics, but the paras and marines have refused. 

Their reasoning is that they are elite troops. Such tactics are considered - by them -  a waste of their talents, a recipe for heavy losses - and beneath their dignity. So far, Russian commanders have refrained from forcing the better trained units to attack in waves, but there is clearly tension as the Ukrainian bridgehead expands. JL

Nathan Rennolds reports in Business Insider:

Russian marines and paratroopers are refusing to launch human wave assaults due to the huge losses other troops are suffering. The soldiers consider "themselves 'elite'" and do not "want to go into frontal assaults" that Storm Z units of former felons and reservists carry out. Russian troops assaulting Ukrainian marine positions at Krynky were being hit with losses of more than 50% while 90% of Russian military equipment deployed around Krynky has been destroyed. One of Russia's newly formed paratrooper units, the 104th Guards Airborne Division, suffered exceptionally heavy losses and failed to achieve its objectives aimed at dislodging Ukrainian positions near Krynky.

Russian marines and paratroopers are refusing to launch certain types of assaults due to concerns over the huge losses other troops are suffering, a Ukrainian official said, the Kyiv Post reported.

Nataliya Humenyuk, a press secretary for the Armed Forces of Ukraine's Joint Command South, said that the soldiers considered "themselves 'elite troops'" and did not "want to go into frontal assaults" that former felons and reservists typically carry out, the outlet reported.

Throughout the Russian invasion, Russia has become increasingly reliant on high-risk frontal assaults involving waves of attacks that probe Ukrainian positions and seize small portions of territory at the cost of substantial casualties.

The leader of the mercenary Wagner Group, Yevgeny Prigozhin, who died in a plane crash last August after leading a failed mutiny in June, described the tactic as a "meat grinder."

\

Humenyuk cited Russian attacks on Krynky in the Kherson Oblast in southern Ukraine, saying that Russian troops assaulting Ukrainian marine positions there were being hit with losses of more than 50%.

"At present in our sector the number of units of the type 'Shtorm-Z' [low-grade Russian units made of up older reservists and former felons, often committed to carry out human wave attacks] is falling and we are seeing more naval infantry and paratroopers," Humenyuk said.

"But they consider themselves 'elite troops,' and they don't want to go into frontal assaults like that," she added.

One of Russia's newly formed paratrooper units, the 104th Guards Airborne Division, appeared to be hit particularly hard in its combat debut in the Kherson region late last year, the UK Ministry of Defence said in an update on the conflict in December.

 

It said the unit "highly likely suffered exceptionally heavy losses and failed to achieve its objectives during its combat debut in Kherson Oblast," aimed at dislodging Ukrainian positions near Krynky.

Krynky has been the scene of heavy fighting over the past few months as Ukrainian forces have attempted to recapture ground across the Dnipro River.

A group of Ukrainian marines sail from the riverbank of Dnipro at the frontline near Kherson, Ukraine, in 2023. 

AP Photo/Alex Babenko

Conditions in the region have made fighting difficult for both sides, with marshes, water-filled bomb craters, and mud making it almost impossible for troops to dig in, The New York Times reported.

Despite Ukrainian officials' claims that the country's marines had gained ground on the eastern side of the river, soldiers and marines told The Times that this was an exaggeration.

 

"There are no positions. There is no such thing as an observation post or position," Oleksiy, a soldier who fought in Krynky and only gave his first name, said. "It is impossible to gain a foothold there. It's impossible to move equipment there."

"It's not even a fight for survival," he added. "It's a suicide mission."

But its success in the skies above the Dnipro bolstered Ukraine's difficult position on the ground.

Russia appears to be struggling to defend against Ukraine's drone attacks because of a shortage of electronic-warfare capability in the area, the UK's Ministry of Defence said.

 

Ukraine's forces have been using first-person-view drones to strike Russian vehicles, the UK Ministry of Defence said in an intelligence update.

The ministry said that a Russian military blogger estimated that 90% of Russian military equipment deployed around Krynky has been destroyed.