Bag the Mortgage: Americans Prioritize Car Payments Over Everything Else

There was a time when Americans' greatest source of wealth and pride was their home. But there was also a time when dinosaurs roamed the earth.

The mortgage debacle of the past four years has sucked much of the value out of homes and exposed the tenuous relationship 'owning' a mortgaged home has had with personal net worth. Stubborn unwillingness to negotiate managable payouts and ruthless foreclosure proceedings leading to historic levels of repossession have also soured people on the value of making nice with banks. Respect is as respect does.

But the American love affair with the automobile is another matter. Recent data show that Americans will make extreme efforts to stay current on their car loans. One reason is that they know it will be hard to get another one. The other - and most pressing - is that so many people need their car to get to work. Growing trends in urbanization and the decline in younger generations' car purchase patterns suggest that consumers are waking up to the mixed blessing of auto dependency; when added to insurance and gas costs, cars have become much more expensive by historical norms, just as national household incomes have declined.

For the time being, cars are first among equals. Consumers know they can always get another credit card and homes? Well, let the bank have the keys, renting is on the rise. JL

The Associated Press reports via Business Insider:

The recession and its hangover may have turned bill-paying habits upside down. Cash-strapped Americans are paying off their car loans before they pay credit card bills and make mortgage payments, a study finds.

It used to be that Americans would pay their home loans first, then their credit card and car loans. After all, homes have been the most valuable possession for most people for decades, and nobody wanted to jeopardize that. But TransUnion, a credit information company, studied the payment patterns of 4 million Americans with at least one car loan, one credit card and a mortgage and found a clear priority for staying current on the car loan

Among Americans who were late on payments last year, 39 percent were delinquent on the mortgage while current on the car loan and credit cards, and 17 percent were late on credit cards while current on the other two.

Only 10 percent were late on the car loan while current on the other two. When TransUnion first did the study in 2006, staying current on the mortgage was the priority, says Ezra Becker, the company's vice president of research and consulting.

"Today, most people need a car to get to a job or to look for a job, and that has made cars a priority," he says.

It hasn't helped that home prices keep falling while the mortgage remains by far the biggest payment for most people. The latest Standard & Poor's/Case-Shiller home price index found that prices in big cities had fallen to 2002 levels, down 34 percent from the peak.

There is also more leeway on the mortgage. Foreclosure can take two to three years. Cars can be repossessed 90 days after people stop paying.

Matt Saxton of Columbia, Md., was not surprised by the study's results. Saxton is on unpaid medical leave from work, recovering from spine surgery and relying on his savings.

Saxton says he dares not be late on his car payment and risk having his car repossessed. Instead, he's decided to be late on his credit cards and student loans.

"I can work with the credit card companies. They won't shut off or take away anything," says Saxton, who made a $474 payment this week. "I won't have the ability to get to work or even get another car if they repossess this one."